RetroPop: Britney Spears and Virginia Woolf—CAUGHT ON TAPE!
Hey there, lovers of current pop music and amazing female writers from the past! Welcome to another edition of RetroPop. This is the space where I normally compare and contrast currently charting female-performed radio tunes with classic texts written by amazing women... but today I thought I'd do something a little bit different and scandalous. Because I'm simply spoiling for a scandale! Don't worry, it's a totally PG-rated scandale.
Last week I came across this list on Buzzfeed of several old "uncut" Britney Spears music videos. Some are full takes from which the editors drew snippets here or there, some are outtakes, some are just rough cuts, and all are mind-blowing, to me at least, as with them Britney's veil of precision and perfection (in her professional life...) has been lifted.
Peeks behind the scenes don't usually make me feel anxious. I mean, I've watched the special features on Human Planet! But in this case the real-ness revealed in the uncut videos definitely evokes some heebie jeebies of discomfort. I suppose it's because my memory of them is that they're flawless, and thus they exist in this nostalgic place in my mind, like Platonic forms of Britney videos or something. It was jarring to me to see these uncut versions and know that the little music videos of sleekness and confidence burned into my memory have "behind the scenes" to them.
It's like that time one of my supply teachers in grade school had a few buttons missing on her blouse and everyone could see her bra but was too afraid to say anything about it. It wasn't a horrible thing, it was just bizarre to see an authority figure in a vulnerable circumstance, betraying that she had flaws. (Incidentally, once someone finally worked up the confidence to tell her, she handled it very well and laughed about it. Way to go, supply teacher whose name I don't remember!)
But once the flaws have been revealed, both with the supply teacher and with Britney as depicted in video form, things are never quite the same again. So just be aware of that before you click these. You can never go back!
The sense of weirdsies I felt reminded me of the first time I heard the voice of my most favourite author, Virginia Woolf, in a recording she did for the BBC narrating one of her essays.
I recently went to a Virginia Woolf book talk/lecture kinda thing at the Brooklyn Library, led by Woolf scholar Anne Fernald. She mentioned this recording of Woolf and noted that when it came to nearly unbelievable voices, Julia Child had nothing on Woolf. Goodness gracious, was she correct!
It was such a completely off-putting experience to hear the real Woolf after having read so, so many of her books and essays and letters imagining a very different voice in my mind. And then it was even MORE off-putting because I felt guilty for having a negative reaction to the voice of this writer who's been so important to my personal and creative development. Was it the idea of her I loved, and when I was confronted with the real thing, I just didn't know what to do? And should I be ashamed of that?
But, then again, isn't that spectator letdown inevitable when our favorite artists and celebrities get caught on tape? What say you?
Comments11 comments have been made. Post a comment.
Have an idea for the blog? Click here to contact us!
vanesarine (not verified)
Peg (not verified)
KJM1280 (not verified)
Sarah Richardson (not verified)