Subscribe to Bitch—an award-winning, 80 page feminist magazine. Image Map

Read the List of 2013's Most Frequently Banned Books

an american flag made from banned books

The Dayton Metro Library created this flag of the 100 most-challenged books from 1990-2000. Photo via Flickr

On Monday of this week, the American Library Association released the list of 2013’s top ten most frequently challenged books. You’d expect it to be packed with racy titles, yes? In fact, seven out of the ten top titles are shelved in a bookstore’s young adult or children’s section.

While it’s tempting to blow off this list’s annual appearance (cue jokes about how 50 Shades of Grey doesn’t really seem to fit on a list along with anything by Toni Morrison), there’s good reason to care: The ALA’s list tells a tale of ongoing censorship and suppression of classic and modern literature in our schools and library systems. Don’t think that colleges are exempt, either—the South Carolina state legislature recently cut $70,000 in funding from two secondary schools for including LGBT-themed literature like Alison Bechdel’s graphic novel Fun Home on required reading lists. While administrators at the targeted South Carolina schools have spoken up for their professors' right to set their own curriculums, hostile actions like that can impact individual teachers’ future decisions about what books to teach. A 1999 study showed that when teachers fear censorship or challenges to the texts they select for classrooms, they tend to rely more on anthologies and the (male-dominated) canon.

Over the past decade, “sexually explicit” has been the biggest reason given for nixing a book from a school or library, with “offensive language,” “unsuited to age group,” “violence,” and “homosexuality” all nipping at its lascivious heels. Most of these reasons bewilder librarian Jessamyn West, the founder of librarian.net and an advocate against censorship. “In most cases, interest indicates age-appropriateness,” says West, who noting that research finds that kids don’t usually like age-inappropriate subject matter anyway.

We also deprive them of an important opportunity, says Tanya Lee Stone, whose book A Bad Boy Can Be Good for a Girl made its first leap onto the list this year. “A book is an incredibly safe place to walk in someone else's shoes without taking risks yourself,” says Stone. So how does she feel about seeing her book, which includes frank portrayals of drugs, nudity, and sex, on the ALA’s list? “Being on the list feels somewhat akin to earning a badge of courage or solidarity, which I will proudly wear,” she says.

2013’s Top Ten Most Frequently Challenged Books:

Captain Underpants (series), by Dav Pilkey: The ongoing saga of two fourth-grade antiheroes doesn’t sit well with some parents, who cited language, age-appropriateness, and violence during challenges across the country. Looks like the read-aloud potty humor that’s rocketed the series up the bestseller charts is also discomfiting to some parents.

The Bluest Eye, by Toni Morrison: Usually Morrison takes a proud place on this list due to her other frequently challenged book, Beloved. But Morrison’s 1970 novel The Bluest Eye, which follows a young black girl who desperately aspires to white beauty standards, has sparked complaints due to its language and graphic descriptions of rape and molestation… even though an estimated one in four girls will experience sexual abuse before she turns 18.

The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, by Sherman Alexie: It’s not entirely clear who objects to this National Book Award for Young People’s Literature-winning book’s so-called racism—author Alexie draws upon his own experiences as a Native American in his story about a boy growing up on the Spokane Indian Reservation. The book has also drawn ire for depictions of sex, drugs, and cussing.

Fifty Shades of Grey, by E.L. James: It’s doubtful that James’s lite bondage sensation has found its way onto any school reading lists yet. Still, challengers cite its religious viewpoint, language, and depictions of sex and nudity when they try to remove it from library shelves.  

The Hunger Games, by Suzanne Collins: The odds are usually in favor of this very popular YA series, but it apparently still incites some people to call for its removal. Collins’s books have been bashed for their non-religious viewpoint and their age-appropriateness, even though the movies based on the series have only earned a PG-13 rating.

A Bad Boy Can Be Good for a Girl, by Tanya Lee Stone: This free-verse novel follows three friends who get mixed up with the same older boy and the consequences of their desire. Parents in school districts nationwide have accused the book of being “pornographic,” objecting to its sexual content, drug depictions, language, and depictions of nudity.

Looking for Alaska, by John Green: With a Printz Award and several weeks on the New York Times bestseller list under its belt, you’d think parents would go gaga for a book about complex teenage experiences. Not exactly: Green’s novel has been called “disgusting” by parents who object to its sex scene, profanity, and portrayal of drugs, alcohol, and smoking.

The Perks of Being a Wallflower, by Stephen Chbosky: This book has been translated into 31 languages and spent over a year on the New York Times bestseller list. But it has earned its place on the ALA list six times since being published due to objections over its discussion of homosexuality and depictions of sex and drug use.

Bless Me Ultima, by Rudolfo Anaya: It’s been 42 years since Anaya’s Chicano classic about spirituality and social change was published. But Anaya’s bruja has earned boos due to its depiction of religious viewpoints and occult/”Satanist” themes.

Bone (series), by Jeff Smith: This award-winning comic book series is known as much for its epic sweep as the epic fits it seems to give some parents. Though its most notable challenge was due to a Minnesota parent who felt it promoted drinking and smoking, the ALA reports it made its way onto this list due to accusations of racism and violence and objections to its political viewpoint. 

Related Reading: New YA Book Great is a Gender-Swapped Reteliing of The Great Gatsby. 

Erin Blakemore is a library school dropout, freelance writer, and author of the Colorado Book Award-winning The Heroine's Bookshelf.


Want the best of Bitch in your inbox? Sign up for our free weekly reader!

Enjoy reading this article? Good news! Our quarterly magazine, Bitch: Feminist Response to Pop Culture, is packed with 80+ pages of feminist analysis, reviews, illustrations, and more. Subscribe today!

Subscribe to Bitch

Comments

7 comments have been made. Post a comment.

Error

Auto-correct got you on Bless Me Ultma

kaitlinw123 Santa Clara, CA

Thanks for the correction!

I made this change—thanks for the heads up!


Bitch Media Online Editor

Problems? Email [email protected]

ps

*Ultima

I have not read the Capt.

I have not read the Capt. Underpants series, but the reasons given for banning it seem silly. My guess is some of the same parents who would 86 this choice are just fine reading such things as tales of witches who fatten up children in order to eat them (aka "Hansel & Gretel") to their kids. In addition, being too obtuse to appreciate Toni Morrison for those under 18 is just sad. Great article, Ms. Blakemore.

ALA Banned Book List is Faked and Harms LGBT Community

The list is a complete fake as admitted by one of the listed authors who revealed her conversation with the ALA at an NJLA convention. I made public my recording of that confession. She was told other books were challenged more than hers but because it dealt with homosexuality and was actually removed, they simply bumped it up on the faked list.

Worse, the ALA has been harming the LGBT community for at least half a decade by falsely giving the impression that opposition to books about homosexuality leads to such books being at the top of the list year after year. The reality is few such books are challenged, then only rarely, but ALA puts them at the top of the list to take advantage of LGBT advocates. Result? Studies show false claims of discrimination against gays results in increased actual discrimination because people think it's okay. Want to see all this for yourselves? Search for "Banned Books Week is Gay Promotion? Author Admits ALA Faked 2010 Top 10 Challenged Book List".

And something I did not yet publish is that ALA does not advise listed authors how many times their books have been challenged. Authors told me that. The answer is so few that this would be a complete non story. Top book of 2010 challenged only 4 times? All year? Across the entire USA? That is about as non story as you can get. Lightning strikes occur far more often.

Media should consider investigating how the American Library Association harms the LGBT community with false discrimination claims before blindly repeating ALA and thereby increasing the harm.

ALA List

Thanks for your information, Dan. Your points are important and ring true. I appreciate this because I have shared the list in Social Media. I don't want to contribute to the very issue I'm advocating against.

After The Absolutely True

After The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-TIme Indian was removed from a school reading list in Meridian, Idaho, I bought it at my local independent book store with the intention of reading it and then mailing it to the library there (the librarian protested the decision of the school board to remove the book from the list). While I was reading it, though, I found out about this: http://www.deathandtaxesmag.com/219767/parents-call-cops-on-teen-for-giv...

So they don't need my copy! The kids are alright. I loved the book; think I'll write to the Meridian school board and thank them for bringing my attention to it.