A Tale of Two Bunnies: Naturi Naughton in Mad Men and The Playboy Club
Those of you who've seen both AMC's Mad Men and NBC's soon-to-be-cancelled The Playboy Club have probably noticed a similarity between the two shows. No, it's not the guy on The Playboy Club who's doing his best Don Draper impression, it's Naturi Naughton, America's favorite "chocolate" Playboy bunny (yes, she is referred to as a chocolate bunny in both shows. Ugh).
Who wore it better? Trick question, you guys.
Though Naughton's being cast as the token black Playboy bunny in both shows might be a mere coincidence (or maybe she owns her own bunny suits), her performances—and the two show's handlings of the complicated race, class, and gender issues a black Playboy bunny might have faced in the early '60s—are begging for a comparison. Let's get to it!
In Mad Men she's Toni Charles, the clandestine love interest of (white, wealthy) Lane Pryce. Though the two clearly care for one another, Toni is the cautious one in the relationship, knowing that her job and possibly her safety is at risk if the wrong people find out about the interracial coupling. Lane, on the other hand, makes an ass out of himself—twice—introducing her to his racist jerk of a dad.
In The Playboy Club, Naughton is Brenda, a nice-seeming woman whose primary goal within the context of the show is to be the first "chocolate centerfold" in Playboy magazine. She mentions encountering racism in the world at large, but says that within the Utopian world of the club "no one can discriminate against these" (referring to her breasts, natch—a line of dialogue most likely written by someone unfamiliar with the racist history surrounding black women's sexuality). Full disclosure: I only watched the first of The Playboy Club's three episodes, but here's Brenda's show bio with a bit more info:
Being a young, African-American woman, Brenda is keenly aware of how the world views her. But inside the Playboy Club, she's safe to dream big. Brenda knows how lucky she is to be a Bunny and doesn't take it for granted. She's close with the other Bunnies and relies on them to keep her in check at times since she can be quite competitive and hotheaded. Sassy and bold, Brenda has no problem telling it like it is—except when it comes to her own family. Her Baptist pastor father thinks she's a schoolteacher in Atlanta, and he'd be furious if he knew the truth. Though she plays the part of a rebellious daughter, deep down Brenda longs for her father's approval.
Screen time and character development:
Toni Charles (note the last name) appeared in only one episode of Mad Men (watch it here), but she was shown both at work and outside of the club, wearing her bunny suit as well as two different modest (and darling) dresses. Though clearly a plot device to complicate Lane's relationship with his father and necessitate his return to England, Toni is nonetheless portrayed as an individual with feelings and an identity beyond "chocolate bunny" (though Lane may be too nearsighted to see it).
Toni Charles, sans bunny suit.
Bunny Brenda (note the lack of last name) gets more screen time on The Playboy Club, but she's still very much a supporting player. We don't see her much outside of the club (though it sounds like her back story was developed a bit in more recent episodes), and we aren't given much insight into her as a person—just her as a bunny. Part of this is because The Playboy Club is about Playboy bunnies, of course, but keep in mind that we have seen some of the other women pursuing interests beyond the club's walls.
Acknowledgment of racism:
Again, Toni is only in one episode of Mad Men. However, in keeping with the show's reputation for nuance, her minute-and-a-half scene interacting with Lane, Don, and Lane's dad in the club is chocked full of racially charged discomfort. It's clear that Lane is using her to show off to and rebel against his dad, and the creepy way in which all three white men stare at her is very different than the (also creepy) way they stared at the white bunnies. Later in the episode, Lane confronts his father about disapproving of Toni because she's black. Racism is certainly acknowledged (though still downplayed—she was only in one episode, after all) and it's racism, combined with Lane's cowardice, that ultimately breaks he and Toni up.
The Playboy Club tries to have it both ways when it comes to racism. They address Brenda's token-ness by mentioning racism and discrimination, but they gloss over it by saying that she's safe and sound inside the club. See what I mean in this short video clip:
Of course, Brenda is also written as "sassy and bold," as well as "competitive and hotheaded" (notice her "welcome to the future, baby" closing line in that promo), which is hardly without racist connotations. On a better show, they'd acknowledge her less-than status within the hierarchy of Playboy bunnies as well as outside it. This is not that show.
Though given a fraction of the screen time, Naughton's character on Mad Men was more three-dimensional and relatable than her recurring role on The Playboy Club. I for one am glad that The Playboy Club is over, because it frees Naughton up for more Mad Men appearances (Attn Matthew Weiner: Bring her back in season five!).
Perhaps a more interesting question to ask, though, is which television show will ask Naturi Naughton to appear next? She's clearly America's pick for "lone 'chocolate' Playboy bunny" roles.
Comments9 comments have been made. Post a comment.
Have an idea for the blog? Click here to contact us!
midge32 (not verified)
Alice A (not verified)
Jason Breen (not verified)
Jason Breen (not verified)
Betty_Smith (not verified)