End of Gender: Not "Just A Tomboy"

At age two, female-assigned Tyler told parents Jean and Stephen he was a boy. After two years, they listened.

Jean and Stephen's support could save Tyler's life, but when their transgender child's story was featured in the Washington Post last week, online commenters accused the parents of overreacting to harmless "tomboyishness."  

"Why would choosing gender even be a consideration for a 2 year old? Is there a possibility that the child picked up on the fact that they got more attention as the opposite sex?" one commenter wrote.

But for Tyler, the disconnect between his brain and his body made him want to hurt himself, a threat that his parents couldn't ignore. If Tyler remains male-identfied as he approaches adulthood, Jean wondered, what will happen to her child's mental heath when female puberty hits? Jean and her husband sought advice from psychiatrists and other parents of transgender kids to learn how to help him.

As psychiatrist Jack Drescher noted in a recent article in the Journal of Homosexuality, children have limited capacity to participate in decision making regarding their own medical treatment. Even adolescents can't legally provide informed consent. That means it's up to parents like Jean and Stephen to advocate for what their kids need. But when those needs involve medical intervention, the situation gets sticky.

Lesbian couple Pauline Moreno and Debra Lobel caused a media uproar in 2007 when they allowed their trangender child, Tammy, to delay male puberty by taking hormone blockers.

"When she's ready, she'll be able to decide which way she's going to go through puberty," Moreno told CNN. "She'll have either female hormones, or she'll stop the hormone blockers and become a man."

"This is child abuse. It's like performing liposuction on an anorexic child," Dr. Paul McHugh, professor of psychiatry at Johns Hopkins University, responded.

But Tammy was so terrified of developing male secondary sex characterists that she was threatening to hang herself—hormone blockers could help her survive.

Puberty blockers are already used among non-trans kids who are experiencing premature puberty. According to Dr. Jennifer Hastings, suspending puberty in trans kids gives them more time to decide what kinds of medical interventions they want or don't want later. Despite what Keith Ablow, my favorite reporter of misinformation, claims, the effects are reversible.

Media commentators who accuse the parents with transgender kids of child abuse cite erroneous claims about hormone blockers, and refuse to acknowledge that children can speak for themselves are missing the life-or-death part of the conversation: Parents who listen to their kids, allow their kids to live as their preferred gender, and guide them through consensual medical decisions are choosing life for their children when the alternative could be far more serious than a temper tantrum.

Check out Gender Spectrum and TransActive for more information about how we can support transgender children.

Previously: Kate Bornstein Saves Lives, Including Her Own: A Review of A Queer and Pleasant Danger, Argentina Grants Gender Self-Determination

Bitch Media publishes the award-winning quarterly magazine, Bitch:Feminist Response to Pop Culture. Pitch in to support feminist media: Subscribe today

Subscribe to Bitch


Comments

3 comments have been made. Post a comment.

Agreed, but I also don't

Agreed, but I also don't necessarily disagree with the first part of the comment quoted - "Why would choosing gender even be a consideration for a two-year-old?" - Children should be free of gender constraints - allow them to play, express themselves however they like - this isn't necessarily 'choosing' a gender. This is just being a kid, especially at young ages. The problem is society's gender binary and the necessity of the term 'transgender children', not necessarily the children who feel out of place.

Agreed!

Agreed!

Thank You for touching on this...

As a young female-identified trans person I appreciate you touching on this issue using my conservative liberal mother as a base board for mainstream thoughts on trans issues I'm always worried that people miss the real issue. Namely, that had I been in that situation I don't see how taking some harmless hormone blockers to delay puberty is equated with child abuse. Especially when the child's death by suicide may result from having to live through a very difficult experience that leaves you permanently marked one way or another. I wish that I could have sorted out my feelings before I had to go through puberty...